Tuesday, April 22, 2014

How (and why) I was fined 2.33 euros

Warning: the first paragraph may induce headache, dizziness, confusion, or nausea, as it is a brief description of various French administrative processes related to setting up a business here. Proceed with caution, and above all, avoid any website which enumerates the different taxes levied on business owners in France.

Whenever I receive a letter from the Préfecture (visa application), the French tax office (income tax, business tax, housing tax, business rental tax, among others...), URSSAF (social benefits for self-employed workers), Ameli (health care, but only for salaried employees; before I started my new business last year, health care was handled by URSSAF, but now that I am salaried, it is handled by Ameli), the Greffe du Tribunal de Commerce de Paris (oversees the founding of a company and its annual reporting), the DIRECCTE (handles issues related to professional development and training, which is the basis of my company), or B2B (a private company that continues to threaten me for not paying into their private retirement fund, but whose threats I patently send directly to the recycling bin), I worry and fret as I open the envelope.

I worry because the laws are confusing here, websites give conflicting information, the phone numbers found on websites ring endlessly and emails often go unanswered for months (aside from some exceptional reactivity from the préfecture – although that is because they kept me in a holding pattern for over 18 months, even though I had a valid visa and they were aware that the technicality blocking my application warranted some TLC on their part). On some occasions, even, the physical address listed on an administrative website is wrong (or out-of-date). I learned this once after hopping into a cab, rushing across town, and attempting to speak to someone at DIRECCTE before the two hour lunch break, but sadly the office had moved outside of Paris. Getting to their new office in Aubervilliers is a story for another day (but in short, my bus broke down and I ended up walking through a ZFU or zone franche urbaine -- which is like an inner-city zone in process of development; companies in those areas receive tax incentives, but the ZFU are also known for the distinction of being rather unsafe, and I had worn unfortunate shoes that day).

Last week I received one of those dreaded envelopes from the Greffe. I was concerned because I had just submitted my annual report, and since it was the first time I’d done so, I wasn’t sure I’d completely understood how to prepare the components. As feared, I had not.

For this story to make sense, let’s go back to April 2013, when I was setting up my new company. As a company with one shareholder (myself), I still have to convene an assembly with the shareholder (myself) to approve all company decisions (that I have made). So after creating the company constitution and getting it approved (by myself) at a meeting (with myself), I sent the minutes from the meeting (with myself) and all other documents to the Greffe. A few weeks later I needed to make an amendment, so I had to host a meeting (with myself), write up the minutes, and approve the decision I had made. I did so with my eyes in a semi-permanent rolled state.

Fast-forward to April 2014, when I had to write up my annual report and send it in to the Greffe. I had read online that a company with only one shareholder need not hold a meeting to approve the annual report, so I omitted this step. My mistake. Apparently the information on that website was incorrect.  The letter I just received from the Greffe has informed me that I have been fined 2,33 euros for not stating explicitly that I, the person who wrote the annual report, and I, the business owner, and I, the sole shareholder, did not explicitly approve of the document that I wrote and sent in. And yes, the fine was really two euros and thirty-three cents.

So today, once I finish regaling you with this little anecdote, I will sit at my desk, write a check for 2.33 euros and then write the minutes to the meeting I will (not--shhh!) have with myself and sign a letter which clearly states that I approve of the work that I completed two weeks ago.

I have been told that the current administration (Hollande, Valls et al.) has plans to streamline the administrative work for small businesses. We’ll see about that…